"Pet 5 Dogs."
I know you can do this by petting one dog 5 times. However, I can't find a single dog in the entirety of the Caribbean. I'm getting kind of frustrated at this point. If someone knows where I could find a dog, could you please post it here? Also, if you could keep an eye out for dogs, in case you happen to stumble across one somewhere, that would be wonderful. I'll keep looking in the meantime.
Have you checked Havana? I recall petting a dog there.
Andreas Island is where I just pet a dog 5 times for the challenge. It's West of Nassau.
Oh my god, thank you so much. I would have been looking for hours. I just got it, you're awesome.
Just got it in Havana... Looks like I was late in reply though, ha
I'd previously explored the majority of Havana and never found one. It's as if my game chose to spawn dogs only at Andreas Island - but now we know that's a guaranteed location! It's a good one to grab it at too, because it's a much smaller surface area to cover.